Assessing Vicarious TCPA Liability: Your Telemarketing Contracts Matter

By Richard NewmanAugust 28, 2017

Vicarious liability is a doctrine that imposes responsibility upon one person/entity for the failure of another, with whom the person/entity has a special relationship.  The doctrine plays an important role in Telephone Consumer Protection Act litigation.

In Jones v. Royal Admin. Servs., Inc., the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently affirmed that traditional agency principles apply when considering whether a telemarketing vendor acted as product/service provider’s authorized agent for purposes of TCPA liability.

In Jones, plaintiffs named the provider as a defendant.  In doing so, plaintiffs claimed that the telemarketer acted as the provider’s agent because the provider had “actual authority” over the telemarketer.  Plaintiffs alleged that the provider, therefore, was vicariously liable for its agent’s telemarketing calls.

The provider’s position was that it was not vicarious liable for the unlawful telemarketing calls because the telemarketer was an independent contractor – not its agent.

In ruling on behalf of the provider, the Ninth Circuit noted that “not all relationships in which one person provides services to another satisfy the definition of agency” and that “[an] individual acting as an ‘independent contractor,’ rather than an agent, does not have the traditional agency relationship with the principal necessary for vicarious liability.”

The extent of control that a provider actually exercises over third-parties that provide call transfers or data is of critical importance. 

Key factors that courts will consider when evaluating whether a provider may be responsible for the actions/omissions of a third-party lead generator include, without limitation:

  • Whether a lead generator is required to maintain records of its interactions with consumers that purchase the applicable products/services;
  • Whether a lead generator is required to provide regular reports on sales and/or cancellation requests;
  • Whether a lead generator is only permitted to utilize the scripts and materials provided/approved by a provider;
  • Whether a lead generator is required to comply with a provider’s guidelines and procedures;
  • Whether a provider trains the telemarketers;
  • Whether the marketing contract reflects an impermanent relationship sufficient to support a finding of independent contractor status;
  • Whether a lead generator provides its own tools, instrumentalities, equipment and place of work;
  • Whether a lead generator sets its own hours and only receives payment if telemarketers actually make a sale;
  • Whether the work is typically performed under supervision;
  • The skill required;
  • The degree of control that a provider exercises over the actual calls at issue; and
  • The subjective intent of the parties.

Takeaway:  The extent of control exercised by a provider over telemarketers and the calls at issue is an essential ingredient in assessing the existence of an agency relationship.  Relationships with third-party call transferors and data sources should take the foregoing factors into account.  Marketing contracts should be examined and deliberately drafted with a forward looking approach in order to minimize vicarious liability exposure and maximize the number of available defenses in the event that the actions of a lead generator result in litigation.

Other Stories You Might Like

Education background: School Board with Row Of White doodle Painted Hand Drawn Science Icons

New Perspectives: Reaching the Top 3 Markers of Postsecondary Student Success
September 18, 2017, 8:00 am

af182af5249fb560054fb0e08689308b_ogimg_100x65_xsmall_thumbnail_1

4 Strategies to Improve Lead Quality at the Time of Conversion
September 14, 2017, 8:00 am

Insurance, Umbrella, Insurance Agent.

Critical Lead Generation Marketing Agreement Provisions
September 13, 2017, 8:00 am

Businessman presses button new customers on virtual screens. Business, technology, internet and networking concept.

Why Branding Influences
September 11, 2017, 9:22 am

50e6bc20fe88a30b185d556b8d66ee2f_feed_1024x567_xlarge_thumbnail_1

How to Create the Perfect Lead Generation Form
September 6, 2017, 8:00 am

35f979c84c50e616c11b182d986b1327_feed_970x450_xlarge_thumbnail_1

How Marketers Can Connect with Technology Distracted Millennial Shoppers
August 31, 2017, 8:00 am

Text get leads button 3d render

How to Avoid the 6 Biggest Pitfalls of Lead Nurturing
August 30, 2017, 8:00 am

9d876161e33f58aa7f7cba22670927e7_ogimg_651x363_xlarge_thumbnail_1

Remarketing Vs. Retargeting: How Google’s Advertising Algorithm Works?
August 29, 2017, 8:00 am

Diversity of Casual People Communication Technology Concept

The Inbound Omnichannel Dilemma – Can You Identify Your Customers?
August 22, 2017, 8:00 am

Education career opportunities concept as a group of graduating university studends crossing a mortarboard or graduation cap acting as a bridge to provide an opportunity and bridging the gap for business success.

The Forever GI Bill: What Military Lead Buyers Need to Know
August 21, 2017, 8:00 am

© 2017 Access Intelligence, LLC – All Rights Reserved. ||